Page 2 of 2

Re: Experience/Feedback Thread

PostPosted: Sat Dec 13, 2014 1:15 pm
by Dark Lord
XP for all Center threads through the end of The Rift Levels

Oradro- 9,100
Metri- 9,800
Zem- 8,250
Alison- 8,700
Starchief- 7,500

Alison, Metri, and Oradro have leveled up. Please update your sheets at your earliest convenience.
Oradro, I will review your submission on the Pantherans and reward an appropriate amount of bonus XP once we get Kesslan transferred over.

Re: Experience/Feedback Thread

PostPosted: Sun Feb 08, 2015 10:16 am
by SNAFU
XP to date:
Oradro: 1375
Starchief: 425
Metri: 650
Zem: 650
Alison: 500
Smiley: 700

Re: Experience/Feedback Thread

PostPosted: Mon Feb 09, 2015 12:24 pm
by Metri
Feedback for: "[GA] The Rift Levels (11-12)" and "The Basement (13-20)" through 2/9/2015

As reflected in DL's rating, I think PW:GA continues to be a top-notch plot with great characters embedded within it. A part of me (likely the part resistant to change) is sad that Icky and Katia are no longer actively playing their characters.

Good:
Remains largely the same...
Metri's last feedback wrote:
  • Over time, DL's GM posts have achieved a level of excellence that pushes me as a player to provide more detail, attempt more internal dialogue and use vivid descriptions in my player posts.
  • Kudos for being able to challenge the wide array of characters in life threatening situations despite the power gradient we have across our characters. Breaking it down into little engagements, having a large amount of weaponsfire focus on Zem... gave the rest of us an opportunity to... not die.
  • I really enjoy the voices some of the players have created for their characters. It is lively, believable and adds to a truly interesting dynamic. (sorry, I definitely needed to say this despite the fact that this feedback thread is for DL. I really think this is an excellent group of RPers we have here)
  • I liked the breadcrumbs DL left for us to follow... the fact that a ship was sighted making landfall on a particular planet. I'm guessing without that tidbit of information, we may have been left floundering for a little while, or even worse, stuck in the grand melee between the Splugorth and Intruders.
  • I am REALLY impressed by how well DL has made our enemies "smarter". A lot of this revolves around utilization of magic (the same sort of magic PCs regularly use against the enemies they fight). I'm guessing that he has had plenty of time developing magic tactics through his Spooks PC Vheld. Woe is us for when DL combines overwhelming arms AND magic combat tactics against us in the future.
  • Entering the moral "grey area" deciding to suppress the rebellion for the "greater good" was excellent. As a player, I continue to wrestle with whether or not GA ultimately made the "right choice".
  • Integration of maps as per previous feedback has been an overall positive IMHO.

  • Regular XP updates as implemented site-wide are great! Gives me a sense that my posting efforts are rewarded.
  • Feels like the post rate has gone up since last feedback. So more story is more fun for me too.

Challenges:
  • Tail end of Rifts Levels (11-12) and Basement (13-20) thread up to this point feels a bit like a holding pattern. What I mean by that is that we continue to encounter and overcome obstacles to moving forward (i.e. Water Elemental/Monster and Center Security) but with little advancement of the story. Perhaps the obstacles' role will become more clear as the plot moves forward, but they both felt a bit... 'unnecessary'. What excites me is the prospect of being assaulted at any time by the Splugorth crew that has been assigned to hunt us. And actually a part of me thought that was what was going to happen both encounters.
  • Player Attrition: Attrition of this sort seems to be a common occurrence in the long timescale of PbP format as real-life often has other plans. In its current state, even the Star Swords remnants who absorbed into Galactic Adventurers are almost lost to attrition. With the impending hiatus of our leader Oradro, a part of me wonders what the "identity" of GA is going to be moving forward.

Re: Experience/Feedback Thread

PostPosted: Sat Feb 14, 2015 11:25 am
by Dark Lord
DSM, please add another 50 XP to Starchief and 100XP to Metri for posting feedback.

Re: Experience/Feedback Thread

PostPosted: Sat Feb 14, 2015 12:26 pm
by Dime Store Magic
Dark Lord wrote:DSM, please add another 50 XP to Starchief and 100XP to Metri for posting feedback.

Done

Re: Experience/Feedback Thread

PostPosted: Wed Jun 03, 2015 4:28 pm
by Dark Lord
XP through this GM update
Oradro - 1350xp | 0.90PPW | XP Per Post 91.7 | (Note: XP has not been added to sheet- transfer to Kesslan after he joins.)
Zem - 1350xp | 0.50PPW | XP Per Post 103.8 | [LEVEL UP]
Starchief - 1525xp | 0.64PPW | XP Per Post 129.2
Metri - 1900xp | 0.90PPW | XP Per Post 93.2
Alison - 1450xp | 0.57PPW | XP Per Post 122.9
Xylek - 1525xp | 1.50PPW | XP Per Post 140.0

Group Post Rate (Weekly): 0.70

Congrats to Zem for reaching Level 8!
As you guys can see, we (particularly I) have some work to do on improving that post rate. At least, I think- I'm going to double-check that I calculated everything correctly before posting this to the main thread. Either way, though, I'll be making that a priority after I get back.

Re: Experience/Feedback Thread

PostPosted: Thu Oct 01, 2015 3:32 pm
by Dark Lord
XP through this GM update

Oradro - 2575xp | 1.07PPW | XP Per Post 161.7 (XP not added to sheet- will transfer to Kesslan)
Metri - 2575xp | 1.07PPW | XP Per Post 171.7
Starchief - 1725xp | 0.79PPW | XP Per Post 143.8
Icky - 2300xp | 1.22PPW | XP Per Post 191.7
Solaris - 1675xp | 1.33PPW | XP Per Post 209.4
Winston - 2200xp | 1.56PPW | XP Per Post 157.1
Xylek - 1700xp | 0.86PPW | XP Per Post 141.7
Zem - 1475xp | 0.57PPW | XP Per Post 184.4

Group Post Rate (Weekly): 1.13

Nobody leveled up, but I'm very happy to see that most of the group's post rates have improved. Those of you who are lagging I would encourage to try to pick up the pace.

Supplemental XP Awards

PostPosted: Fri Nov 20, 2015 9:11 am
by Dark Lord
DSM, the next time you add XP to sheets please add the following bonuses:

Kesslan- 1000XP for an excellent background addition, + 150 for posting feedback at the end of last quadrimester.
Icky- +25 XP for posting feedback.
Winston- +150 for posting feedback.
Solaris- +75 XP for posting feedback.

Note also that for several of the above XP awards, Oradro earned XP that still needs to be applied to Kesslan. Once I have approved his sheet for play, please add that to Kesslan's tally as well. I still need to go through a couple of the supplemental materials Kesslan wrote up for us, but that will have to wait.

EDIT: Forgot Zem gave me some feedback too. +150XP for him.

Re: Experience/Feedback Thread

PostPosted: Mon Nov 23, 2015 1:44 pm
by Dime Store Magic
DL request XP be tabulated early as a Thanksgiving gift to you all. Gobble, Gobble.

Post per week calculation is still based on the whole quadrimester. I've added Quality post count as well if you are on the EP hunt, i.e. 15 posts = 1 EP, 22 posts = 2 EP by the end of the period.

XP from October 1, 2015 to November 23, 2015 @1:33pm.

Galactic Adventurers

Oradro/Kesslan - 5925xp | 0.79PPW | XP Per Post 493.8 | QP: 11

Adding 1350+2575+5925 = 9850 to Kesslan per prior agreement with DL.

Metri - 2825xp | 0.29PPW | XP Per Post 403.6 | QP: 4
Starchief - 4650xp | 0.50PPW | XP Per Post 465.0 | QP: 7
Icky - 4575xp | 0.43PPW | XP Per Post 381.3 | QP: 6
Solaris - 4975xp | 0.57PPW | XP Per Post 497.5 | QP: 8 | [LEVEL UP]
Winston - 4750xp | 0.64PPW | XP Per Post 431.8 | QP: 9 | [LEVEL UP]
Emerson - 75xp | 0.20PPW | XP Per Post 75.0 |QP: 1

Zem - 4425xp | 0.43PPW | XP Per Post 346.9 |QP: 6

Group Post Rate (Weekly): 0.54

Re: Experience/Feedback Thread

PostPosted: Thu Dec 03, 2015 1:34 pm
by Dark Lord
Kesslan has been awarded an additional 2500 XP for his excellent write-up on the Pantherans in the Three Galaxies, which will be transferred to the Game Notes forum and made officially part of the setting. His character sheet has likewise been updated.

Re: Experience/Feedback Thread

PostPosted: Mon Feb 01, 2016 8:44 am
by Dime Store Magic
Galactic Adventurers

XP from 11/23/2015 forward, the post rate and XP per post is for the full quadrimester.

Kesslan - 4275xp | 2.43PPW | XP Per Post 255.0 | [LEVEL UP]

Kesslan's total includes 2500 XP for Pantheran History awarded by DL.

Metri - 325xp | 0.43PPW | XP Per Post 350.0 | [LEVEL UP]
Starchief - 1150xp | 1.36PPW | XP Per Post 263.6 | [LEVEL UP]
Icky - 775xp | 1.07PPW | XP Per Post 212.5
Solaris - 1075xp | 1.50PPW | XP Per Post 263.0
Winston - 775xp | 1.14PPW | XP Per Post 230.2
Emerson - 2100xp | 1.91PPW | XP Per Post 103.6
Zem - 325xp | 0.71PPW | XP Per Post 258.3

Group Post Rate (Weekly): 1.41

Great job team posting through the Holiday slow down.

Re: Experience/Feedback Thread

PostPosted: Mon May 30, 2016 6:56 pm
by Dime Store Magic
Galactic Adventurers

Kesslan - 4050xp | 2.21PPW | XP Per Post 130.6 | [LEVEL UP] | 3 EP Reward
Metri - 1675xp | 0.93PPW | XP Per Post 128.8
Starchief - 1325xp | 0.86PPW | XP Per Post 110.4
Icky - 1750xp | 1.14PPW | XP Per Post 110.0 | 1 EP Reward
Solaris - 1900xp | 1.14PPW | XP Per Post 118.8 | 1 EP Reward
Winston - 1700xp | 1.07PPW | XP Per Post 108.3 | 1 EP Reward
Zem - 1675xp | 0.79PPW | XP Per Post 152.3

Group Post Rate (Weekly): 1.23

So, I know that there are 31 days in May, but I decided to bow to peer pressure.

Emerson has been removed from the post rate calculation.

Edit: Updated to include last May posts by Chef Icky and Winston

Re: Experience/Feedback Thread

PostPosted: Mon May 30, 2016 7:58 pm
by Winston
Boo, iwas gonna be home to post tomorrow!

Re: Experience/Feedback Thread

PostPosted: Tue May 31, 2016 12:58 pm
by Rufus
Dime Store Magic wrote:So, I know that there are 31 days in May, but I decided to bow to peer pressure.


I read this and can just hear the stereotypical parental comeback: "If everyone jumped off a cliff, would you do it too?"

Re: Experience/Feedback Thread

PostPosted: Sat Oct 01, 2016 5:20 am
by Dime Store Magic
Galactic Adventurers
Kesslan - 4025xp | 1.57PPW | XP Per Post 183.0 | [LEVEL UP] | Recommend 2 EP
Metri - 2500xp | 1.07PPW | XP Per Post 166.7 | Recommend 1 EP
Starchief - 2500xp | 1.07PPW | XP Per Post 166.7 | Recommend 1 EP
Icky - 3575xp | 1.07PPW | XP Per Post 238.3 | [LEVEL UP] | Recommend 1 EP
Solaris - 2875xp | 1.14PPW | XP Per Post 179.7 | Recommend 1 EP
Winston - 2200xp | 0.93PPW | XP Per Post 169.2
Tis - 275xp | 1.00PPW | XP Per Post 91.7
Zem - 2275xp | 0.93PPW | XP Per Post 175.0


Group Post Rate (Weekly): 1.14

Re: Experience/Feedback Thread

PostPosted: Wed Feb 01, 2017 8:33 am
by Dime Store Magic
Galactic Adventurers
Kesslan - 3325xp | 1.29PPW | XP Per Post 184.7 | Recommend 1 EP
Metri - 1275xp | 0.43PPW | XP Per Post 212.5
Starchief - 1900xp | 0.71PPW | XP Per Post 140.0
Icky - 2125xp | 1.00PPW | XP Per Post 151.8
Solaris - 2275xp | 1.29PPW | XP Per Post 93.4 | [LEVEL UP] | Recommend 1 EP
Winston - 2425xp | 1.14PPW | XP Per Post 151.6 | [LEVEL UP] | Recommend 1 EP
Tis - 2000xp | 1.14PPW | XP Per Post 117.6 | Recommend 1 EP
Zem - 800xp | 0.21PPW | XP Per Post 100.0

Group Post Rate (Weekly): 1.00

Re: Experience/Feedback Thread

PostPosted: Thu Jun 01, 2017 7:28 am
by Dime Store Magic
Galactic Adventurers
Kesslan - 3150xp | 2.07PPW | XP Per Post 108.6 | Recommend 3 EP
Starchief - 1550xp | 1.14PPW | XP Per Post 96.9 | Recommend 1 EP
Icky - 1025xp | 0.71PPW | XP Per Post 102.5 |
Solaris - 1550xp | 1.14PPW | XP Per Post 96.9 | Recommend 1 EP
Winston - 2025xp | 1.43PPW | XP Per Post 101.3 | Recommend 1 EP
Tis - 1750xp | 1.14PPW | XP Per Post 109.4 | Recommend 1 EP

Group Post Rate (Weekly): 1.27

Re: Experience/Feedback Thread

PostPosted: Sun Oct 01, 2017 5:46 am
by Dime Store Magic
Galactic Adventurers

Kesslan - 2975xp | 0.79PPW | XP Per Post 188.6 | [LEVEL UP] | 50 Milestone XP Boost Used, XP = 5950
Metri - 6075xp | 1.64PPW | XP Per Post 264.1 | Recommend 2 EP
Starchief - 3225xp | 1.00PPW | XP Per Post 230.4
Icky - 250xp | 0.07PPW | XP Per Post 250.0
Solaris - 4050xp | 1.36PPW | XP Per Post 211.8 | Recommend 1 EP
Winston - 2500xp | 0.79PPW | XP Per Post 227.3
Tis - 3025xp | 0.93PPW | XP Per Post 232.7
Thought - 1525xp | 0.63PPW | XP Per Post 305.0

Group Post Rate (Weekly): 0.94

Re: Experience/Feedback Thread

PostPosted: Thu Feb 01, 2018 1:50 pm
by Rogue Trader
Galactic Adventurers

Starchief - 3500xp | 0.79PPW | XP Per Post 318.2
Metri - 2950xp | 0.75PPW | XP Per Post 327.8
Solaris - 4725xp | 1.14PPW | XP Per Post 295.3 | [LEVEL UP] | RECOMMEND 1 EP
Tis - 3825xp | 0.71PPW | XP Per Post 382.5
Winston - 2950xp | 0.78PPW | XP Per Post 421.4 | [LEVEL UP]
Kiadan - 475xp | 1.00PPW | XP Per Post 237.5
Thought - 4900xp | 1.14PPW | XP Per Post 306.3 | [LEVEL UP] | RECOMMEND 1 EP


Group Post Rate (Weekly): 0.89

Re: Experience/Feedback Thread

PostPosted: Fri Jun 01, 2018 9:32 am
by Rogue Trader
Galactic Adventurers
Starchief - 3850xp | 0.86PPW | XP Per Post 195.8
Metri - 4100xp | 0.86PPW | XP Per Post 216.7 | [LEVEL UP]
Solaris - 5925xp | 1.64PPW | XP Per Post 192.4 RECOMMEND 2 EP
Tis - 4525xp | 0.93PPW | XP Per Post 232.7 | [LEVEL UP]
Kiadan - 2075xp | 1.00PPW | XP Per Post 293.8
Chef Icky - 3875xp | 1.22PPW | XP Per Post 215.9 RECOMMEND 1 EP
Thought - 2750xp | 0.50PPW | XP Per Post 312.5 | [LEVEL UP]
Juan Echo - 2000xp | 1.25PPW | XP Per Post 280.0 RECOMMEND 1 EP

Group Post Rate (Weekly): 1.00